Recieved my tub of PES Frosted Sugar Cookie yesterday and made a shake with crushed ice and 2% Fairlife. I don't know, might be my tastebuds off due to my Ulcerative Colitis or flavors not as great as I remembered (also could be my blender being old and making things taste "off") but wasn't as amazing as I used to recall their flavors being. Was still good and pretty close to named flavor I would say but still need to use more to get a final verdict. I will try in just fairlife today not blended with ice to see how that tastes.